Streaming The Best, Worst and Weirdest Christmas Albums on Spotify
I get it, you’re suspicious of me writing this article, how can I - a convert to Taoism review Christmas albums with the authentic believer in the Christmas holiday miracle? Well, you’ve forgotten I was raised in a Christian household half my life and I’m mostly into the season for the elves. Gotta love those elves. Anyway, I have a fondness for Christmas music which transcends mere theological boundaries, if Jewish people can get away with recording Christmas music, a Taoist can get away with listening to it. And boy have I heard a lot of Christmas music over the years, both good and terrible. Spotify underpays artists a pittance for streaming on their platform, so when I find a good album I tend to buy it on CD or vinyl, but when it comes to Christmas releases I hesitate to throw money down unless they’re worth my time. I don’t have a large collection of Christmas albums, mostly the A Charlie Brown Christmas soundtrack and the Phil Spector Christmas album (which my family hates because they think the Silent Night track with Phil Spector’s voice on it sounds creepy), but I’ve tried to diversify this year and I’ll talk about that later on. For now, expect a whole lot of Yuletide dross I’ve sifted through to find the holiday gold. Much of the music churned out for Christmas is mediocre garbage, but I hope to spotlight my favourite obscurities in the so bad it’s good category as well as the better angels among the mainstream ones you can find circulated by Spotify for posterity’s sake if nothing else. I’m starting to understand why people hate Christmas music having listened to so many of these recordings which cover the same songs over and over, but I persevere for the culture. Pray for me as I plumb the depths of Christmas past, present and future..
A Twisted Christmas (Twisted Sister)
For some reason a recurring theme in Twisted Sister’s music videos is some stuck up snob or authority figure refusing to listen to Twisted Sister’s brand of hair metal, like the PMRC is still breathing down their necks after all these years. Released in the early two-thousands, this element of their legacy is still present even on their Christmas album, which isn’t half bad. I like metal music a lot, and seldom does its brutal realm and the world of Christmas albums meet. What you get here is a bunch of standards like Oh Come Oh Ye Faithful and I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus crooned by Dee Snider, it is often derided as one of the worst Christmas albums ever recorded, however I kinda dig its audacity to exist. It encapsulates everything Dee Snider is as a performer, lending his personality as a lead singer to over-familiar Christmas carols which needed a metal makeover to renew interest in them. Twisted Sister’s rendition of Let It Snow has a little bit of Black Sabbath in its grinding guitars accompanied by sleigh bells, it genuinely rules.
Christmas (Michael Buble)
I first heard Michael Buble through his cover of I’m Your Man by Leonard Cohen, which I listened to while I was being assaulted by a small child bashing my head with a plastic hammer - which I tolerated because I had lost the will to live. That’s a terrible first impression for Michael Buble to leave on me, so I figured checking out his Christmas album for free on Spotify couldn’t hurt because nobody respects Christmas music and he was leaving poor Leonard Cohen alone. The version of the album available on Spotify is the Deluxe Special Edition, which is a punishing hour and eight minutes in length. I don’t think I can handle that much Buble in one sitting, but I must for the purposes of this blog. This album escaped to plague an unsuspecting public in 2011, which feels so long ago, and Michael Buble’s bland white crooner shtick is no Christmas With The Rat Pack by any stretch, not even as a Shania Twain tragic could he win me over with a duet with her on the track White Christmas. Most egregious is Buble’s cover of Santa Baby, which wins the award for most no-homo vibes ever recorded on a Christmas album as he attempts to get a Rolex under the tree on the basis of being “buddies” with Santa. Say what you will about A Twisted Christmas, Dee Snider stamps his mark on Christmas classics which isn’t easy to forget, whereas whenever I hear Michael Buble I can’t distinguish him from most other white guys singing Christmas songs on the loudspeaker at the mall in December. There are much better renditions of these songs out there, by underrated artists who are dwarfed by the success of this middle of the road Christmas album, and this is somehow the version of these songs a lot of people have chosen to hear. Bah humbug!
A Holly Dolly Christmas (Dolly Parton)
One of the most recent entries in the Christmas album canon, which isn’t her first rodeo with Christmas albums (she collaborated with Kenny Rogers on one called Once Upon A Christmas in the eighties), Dolly Parton delivers a charming if cheesy LP for the holiday season amidst releasing a book and funding a vaccine for COVID-19. What can’t she do? As a Christmas record, this is among the best releases I’ve heard since John Legend’s A Legendary Christmas. It’s one of the less secular Christmas albums I’ve heard in a long time too, Dolly is unafraid to mention Jesus as the reason for the season on tracks like Mary, Did You Know? which closes the album out on a melancholy note. Cuddle Up, Cosy Down Christmas features my nemesis, Michael Buble, however I cannot dare to question the creative decisions of Dolly despite having a duet with Jimmy Fallon on All I Want For Christmas Is You. Christmas Is presents us with a sobering reminder that Christmas is a time for giving (it’s all about kindness according to Dolly), meanwhile Christmas On The Square is a country-flavoured good time, even if it was featured in the terrible Netflix musical of the same name isn’t enough to sour it for me. Dolly’s rendition of I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus is a prime slice of cheese which no other artist could get away with in 2020, but Dolly Parton’s sincerity cleaves through any irony poisoning that would dismiss this record as too corny to match the grim mood of the times we’re in. I enjoyed A Holly Dolly Christmas a fair bit, silliness and all, and you can do so much worse.
Only Santa Knows (Delta Goodrem)
A refreshing change of pace from Afroman’s A Colt 45 Christmas, Australian starlet Delta Goodrem’’s Only Santa Knows delivers a decent entry into 2020’s Christmas album slate which gave us A Holly Dolly Christmas and A Very Trainor Christmas. It stands alongside Olivia Newton John and John Farnham’s Friends for Christmas as a representative of its genre, and doesn’t have any nasty surprises. Only Santa Knows is a pleasant title track, comparisons to Mariah Carey’s Merry Christmas album are inevitable but I’d still prefer this over Michael Buble any day. The absence of another cover of Baby, It’s Cold Outside is both welcome and notable, as well as no tired cover of Paul McCartney’s Wonderful Christmastime. Delta mostly sticks to the classics like Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer and Rocking Around The Christmas Tree, however she does distinguish herself on other presumable original tracks like River and Grown Up Christmas List. I haven’t paid much attention to Delta Goodrem when she dropped her most famous album Innocent Eyes, and checking up on her Christmas album confirmed she’s still got it as a pop diva. Only Santa Knows is worth streaming if you are unfamiliar with one of Australia’s treasures.
Christmas In The Heart (Bob Dylan)
Bob Dylan’s singing voice is divisive to say the least, and that definitely applies to this LP where his voice is front and centre on tracks like Must Be Santa (which is a banger). Bob Dylan takes a break from his counter-cultural experimentation to record Christmas songs for the holiday season. I admit Bob’s voice got some getting used to here, but when I got into the groove this was a rewarding entry in the Christmas album canon. I may not be the biggest Bob Dylan fan out there, but I sure as hell respect him, his cover of Do You Hear What I Hear? is at least memorable and interesting if a bit raspy. Here Comes Santa Claus is an enjoyable opening track, Winter Wonderland is delightful in Bob Dylan’s hands, his take on Hark The Herald Angels Sing is a bit abrasive for my taste. But I doubt Christmas In The Heart deserves to rot in the category of worst Christmas albums as I’ve seen on some listicles online. I’ll Be Home For Christmas demonstrates why some listeners might be put off, I’d still rather listen to Bob Dylan sing The Little Drummer Boy than endure an entire album of Michael Buble again. I know it sounds like I’m damning this thing with faint praise, but Christmas In The Heart deserves your attention as long as you accept the terms and conditions that it’s a Bob Dylan LP, not a polished pop star LP.
Holiday For Swing! (Seth MacFarlane)
Comparisons to Michael Buble are inevitable here, as Seth MacFarlane of Family Guy fame tries his hand at Christmas music in the tradition of Rat Pack performers before him. The song selection is solid enough for an album such as this, Christmas Dreaming is rather pleasant but I still can’t shake the fact that the creator of American Dad of all things is crooning Christmas staples whilst trying to sound like Frank Sinatra on I’ll Be Home For Christmas. The production on this record evokes nostalgic sixties Christmas tones, a real classy affair is what Seth’s going for here, and for the most part he succeeds despite his reputation for low-brow crass humour.. Little Jack Frost Get Lost is a charming duet with Norah Jones on a lesser known Christmas song, I kinda liked it and it’s accompanied by a big band sound. A Marshmallow World is a track I’m familiar with from the Phil Spector Christmas album, and I’ve gotta say I prefer the original better because I’m biased to that one due to over-familiarity, What Are You Doing New Year’s Eve? is one I’ve never heard before Seth’s take on it and thus I feel the reverse to it. Of course we’re subjected to Seth’s rendition of Baby, It’s Cold Outside - a song which has gotten controversial over the years and ever since I heard the Idina Menzel version I’ve been aware the male character in that song is rather pushy. Seth McFarlane’s take on Baby, It’s Cold Outside doesn’t break any new ground, but it does retain the “what’s in this drink?” line which some popular versions excise. I know I’m harping on this, but after you hear so many distinct versions of the same song I have gripes to share about individual recordings of it I guess. Mele Kalikimaka is an island themed track which Seth does his best old school crooner take on and you wouldn’t feel out of place hearing this one at your local sophisticated tiki bar. Warm In December is a jazzy little number which Seth lends his Rat Pack sensibilities to well, and compared to crap like A Colt 45 Christmas he’s downright bring home to mother material in terms of style and presentation. Hidden depth is the theme of this record, I never thought the mind behind KISS Saves Santa had an enjoyable take on Moonlight In Vermont in him, (Everybody’s Waitin’ For) The Man With The Bag ain’t bad either, Seth’s cohesive vision for this album overcomes the obstacle of taking MacFarlane’s non-cartoon side-projects seriously. The Christmas Song closes out the LP, at which point I wonder if Seth MacFarlane is trapped within a dude-bro prison of his own making via the television shows he makes. It’s a bit like hearing Disturbed cover The Sound of Silence and discovering David Dramian’s undiscovered talent emerge.
Christmas In Tha Dogghouse (Snoop Dogg Presents)
Snoop Dogg wills into being yet another contribution to the gangsta Christmas sub-genre, this time dragging various artists along with him to create this record similar to the previous Christmas On Death Row. The production on this thing is amazing, updated for the new millennium, and Snoop Dogg welcomes you to the album on Christmas Intro with class and prestige. Christmas In Tha Dogghouse promises from the get go to let you get your groove on, and it is a promise kept on tracks like Xmas On Soul and This Christmas. The album sets a tone of hip-hop togetherness with your homies, like most rap albums centred around Christmas there is the slightest dark undertone of the ghetto reality lurking beneath these beats but nothing too rough to give you emotional whiplash upon listening to it. A Gift That Keeps On Giving presents us with a hood Christmas vibe, thugged out for the holidays. A New Xmas continues that mood with a song about hustling and being your own Santa Claus, as well as rolling blunts and counting that paper. I Miss Them Days is a nostalgic look at Christmas parties of the past, which has a neat sample driving its momentum, A Very Special Christmas has an R&B flavour going on. Twas The Night Before Xmas has a twinge of social commentary about being from a poor family at Christmas time and being robbed by a crackhead stealing presents from under the tree, My Little Mama Trippin On Xmas is a tale about trying to get with a hot girl at school around Christmas, which has a twinkling melody. Just Like Xmas is built around a quality chorus, referencing “that old CD from the Row” as a throwback to past holiday albums Snoop Dogg has appeared on, plus thanking the Lord and being grateful is a virtue expressed here. Look Out is a song about poverty in the hood on Christmas, with a hint of social commentary about how your momma can be Santa Claus when you’re poor, that gets interrupted by bragging about popping bottles and sipping on the Christmas bong now that the narrator is an adult. When Was Jesus Born? contemplates the reason for the season over hip-hop beats, as well as momma paying the bills. Xmas Trees is about getting high from the Christmas bong, in addition to New Year’s Weed, I kinda liked this track about growing marijuana in your own nursery, Every Day Is Like Christmas To Me is a brag-rap about outgrowing Santa Claus and ballin’. Christmas In The Hood is a funky little jam about being trying to avoid being robbed by crackheads and spending December 24th in the county jail, The Grinch is about what you would expect from that title; a riff on the famous villainous Christmas character created by Dr. Seuss as “the Grinch who stole anything” boasts that he’ll rob Lil Wayne for his grill. The album’s final tracks include Landy In My Egg Nog and A Pimp’s Christmas Song, which are fine songs to go out on Looking back on this album it’s a product of its time (2008) but it’s a unique and enjoyable Christmas record which deserves your attention.
Death Metal Christmas (J.J. Hrubovcak)
A short but not sweet EP of desecrated Christmas carols, J.J. Hrubovcak transmogrifies God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen into Unrest for Melancholy Men and We Three Kings into Earthen Kings like a Chaos Space Marine putting spikes and chains and skulls onto a captured Imperium Predator tank. Complete with death metal reimagining of The Nutcracker Suite’s Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy and Greensleeves, this Death Metal Christmas album subtitled Hellish Renditions of Christmas Classics has something for every headbanger if Twisted Sister are too hair metal for you.
Christmas Songs (Bad Religion)
I’m not too familiar with Bad Religion outside of their inclusion on the Tony Hawk Pro Skater 2 soundtrack, however I do know them by reputation as one of the best punk bands ever formed. They recorded an album of Christmas songs which consists of classic carols done in their ripping punk style, and to be honest I prefer their approach to Christmas songs over the Twisted Sister A Twisted Christmas album. I don’t have a lot to say about this one except that I enjoyed it a lot and it includes a remix of their biting satirical song American Jesus off Recipe For Hate - devastating in its inclusion here as an indictment of the American saviour who replaces the biblical one for the evangelical right wing. Un-ironic rocking out is to be had here, with enthusiastic recommendation.
Hung For The Holidays (William Hung)
I take back anything bad I might have said about A Twisted Christmas, this album here is truly awful, right down to the cheap Casio instrumentation on display. I have never heard of this William Hung guy, apparently he was a reality TV flame-out and I believe that. The fact Spotify keeps this album in circulation is a slight against the platform, I didn’t need to hear this guy butchering Silver Bells and The Little Drummer Boy even though such vital research was self-inflicted. Not a single song on this so-called album is good, and all of them are sung off-key by William Hung.. Afroman’s A Colt 45 Christmas was offensive for its dated humour, this is aesthetically offensive in its shoddy and chintzy production that drags down its quality to a nadir of Christmas music recordings. Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer gets slaughtered on this thing which was pressed to CD at some point, poor Winter Wonderland is abused in similar fashion. Not even worth the ironic consumption, William Hung’s mangling of We Are The Champions in a hidden track called Greetings: Hopes And Dreams makes me yearn for the dulcet tones of Seth MacFarlane.
A Very Spidey Christmas (Various Artists)
Released to promote Spider-Man: Enter The Spider-Verse, this EP titled A Very Spidey Christmas doesn’t overstay its welcome, with a version of Joy To The World and Spidey-Bells (A Hero’s Lament) being strong highlights as Chris Pine regrets his choices in life.. I like this EP a lot for what it is, a novelty Christmas record dedicated to Spider-Man-centric parodies of classic carols like Deck The Halls, it’s a lot more comedy focused than most Christmas albums out there, I suppose if you’re one of those people who hate all superheroes you probably won’t like this either but I dig it. The EP closes out on The Night Before Christmas 1967 (Spoken Word) and it’s filled with references to Spidey-senses. I suppose this is a fine EP to stop my retrospective on Christmas albums available on Spotify and I hope you all had fun as I close out this miserable year 2020. Have a Merry Christmas and a much happier New Year, I subjected my ears to a lot of crap doing this and I hope my delving into Spotify’s depths has entertained you these holidays.